What We Use for Deer Repellents
Back in the day when we had a landscaping business in Asheville, NC, one of our Biltmore Forest customers asked us to do something about the deer destroying her prized hostas and other plantings. This was thirty some years ago and there weren’t many legal and non-lethal solutions.
Lacking apex predators, the deer population had grown into a major nuisance. We pondered the solution and decided to experiment with a homemade repellent that would make the deer think a predator was lurking about. The Asheville Zoo accommodated us with a bucket of fresh mountain lion poop!
We placed the lion poop in little bags of cheesecloth and hung around the lady’s yard. An unpleasant job, to say the least, but it worked! Still, it was a lot of stinking trouble!
Nowadays, there are so many options for keeping the deer (and other critters) away from our gardens and landscape. But which deer deterrent is most effective in keeping deer off of plants and out of the garden?
The deer repellent we’re using with success and added benefit, is Milorganite.
1. A Great Discovery
We first heard of Milorganite for deer repellent from an old-timer at a local supply store. I asked him what he used to keep deer out and whether he used fencing, and he said “No, no.. Milorganite.”
So we bought some for deer repellent, only to discover another benefit: Milorganite is a deer repellent and fertilizer! Now we use Milorganite as a fertilizer that also repels deer. We have it around fruit and nut trees and other young trees, and in and around our straw bale garden.
We appreciate the recycling ingenuity that engineered this product. However the drawback in using it for deer is that it does require frequent replenishment. Whenever we’ve fallen short on reapplying, the pesky deer have taken advantage, so it needs to be applied regularly. We’re applying it roughly twice a month, but if you have a heavy rain, you might need an interim application.
Milorganite works well as deer repellent so long as it’s applied regularly.
Having delved into the topic of elderberries for an article, they looked like a great addition to our “upper garden”. We set out four Elderberry plants (2 Yorks and 2 Adams) and they were doing quite well. And can you guess what happened?
That’s right, the deer discovered three of them and nibbled off most all of the leaves and flower heads. We’d not applied any Milorganite and were pretty naive about the deer having plenty else to eat. So, to prevent further damage, we’ve been periodically (after good rains) applying about 2 cups in a circle around each elderberry. In just two and a half weeks, here’s what we have now.
Deer herds roam through our yard on a regular basis and they’ve not touched the elderberries since the application.
We also took measures to protect our new planting of Jerusalem Artichoke, which the deer devoured last summer. Again, there’s no sign of grazing or even nibbling. Yay!!
Applying about 2 cups of Milorganite in a circle around each plant has kept it protected from deer. Just be sure to reapply after a heavy rain.
See also, research on the efficacy of Milorganite as a deer repellent.1)http://www.milorganite.com/tools-and-resources/research
2. A Fence is the Very Best Deer Defense
The ultimate best solution for deer is a high fence. Of courses fences cost more and take more to install. However, consider that once you have it in place, it should serve for years to come.
A fence is a bigger up front investment for a much bigger long term gain.
The Upside – Downside of a Fence
If you just have a smaller, contained garden area, that might be the way to go. Otherwise, it’s not just any ole fence will do when it comes to deer.
Edible Landscaping Nursery2)http://ediblelandscaping.com/ shared that they had to finally deploy an 8 foot fence and a string of electric fencing atop that because of course deer can jump. The end result has been quite effective, and while costly, especially for a nursery with lots of acreage, once it’s done your deer worries are over. (Then you can focus on the rabbits and moles)!?
3. Our Best Deer and Squirrel Repellent
The other thing we’re using this year to keep deer, cats, dogs and squirrels away with good results so far, is a Hoont Motion Activated Water Blaster.
While the deer can adapt to certain odor deterrents, they’re much less likely to stick around when something starts vibrating, rotating, “clucking” and spraying them with water. The added advantage of a motion activated rotating power sprinkler is that it’s also helps to keep the nemesis-of-our-tomatoes at bay: the squirrels!
So far, the Hoont motion sensor repellent also keeps away squirrels, cats and dogs from our garden—thankfully—because we lost way too many tomatoes to the squirrels last year!
In fact, this year, we’re adding two more to take care of a few areas left unprotected by the squirrels as they got smart and found a dry pathway to the tomatoes.
What we like most about the motion sensor repellants:
1. They work to deter squirrels and deer
2. They also add a little water to the garden at the same time, so it’s not wasted
4. The Best Deer Repellent Plants
This is our most favorite deer repellent solution because it’s about planting and growing! If we can design our garden landscape to be surrounded by plants that deer do not like to eat, we have a good chance of creating a “living” functional fence that provides beauty and even food, all while serving to keep the deer away.
Perennial Deer Repellent Plants
- Allium – ornamental allium
- Armeria – aka thrift; sea pink
- Beardtongue – penstemon
- Bee Balm – Monarda
- Blackeyed Susan – (most are perennial)
- Catmint – Nepeta
- Centaurea – cornflower
- Clethra alnifolia
- Digitalis – Foxglove
- Festuca – blue fescue
- Fountain grass – pennisetum
- Lamb’s Ears
- Miscanthus – Porcupine Grass
- Rugosa roses
- Russian sage – perovskia
- Veronica – speedwell
5. Dogs as Deer Deterrents
We’ve really enjoyed hearing how our fellow garden aficionados deal with deer and other four legged invaders, so if you haven’t joined in the conversation on our Facebook Page, please drop in for a visit!
What about dogs?
Many in the Gardens All community say their dogs are highly effective at keeping deer away from their garden. So that can work if you have an outdoor dog, but ours are indoor/outdoor dogs that sleep inside and tend to be wherever we are, which means they often miss the deer.
Other Disadvantages to Dogs:
Dogs barking frequently or incessantly, as outdoor dogs are inclined to do, isn’t a pleasant neighborhood experience. We have an electric dog fence, so the other liability is that our dogs could be motivated enough to “run the line” if they were actually chasing wildlife. It would be awful to lose them that way, so the dog defense just isn’t a viable or preferable option for us right now.
Hey… we love deer and enjoy seeing them crossing through our property, but these are the only kind of deer we would want in our garden! (Thought these were super cool, so included them). ?
Cheap and Effective Deer Repellent
Meanwhile, if you’re into DIY, for a cheap but effective homemade deer alarm system that even trains the deer to stay away, you’ll want to read on and watch Beau’s video.
TRAIN THE DEER TO STAY AWAY!
Here’s what Beau Ouimette says about his homemade deer fence:
This is how I keep deer out of my garden. It works every year. It is safe for pets and costs almost nothing to install. I live in Western Maryland and we have tons of deer here!
THANKS Beau for sharing this awesome tip!
And… related articles you may enjoy these related articles:
How to Keep Rodents, Rabbits, Squirrels and Insectivores Out of the Garden
Earwigs in the Garden and How to Get rid of Pincher Bugs
How to Attract Birds that Eat Mosquitos and Bad Garden Bugs
Let’s Keep on Growing!
References [ + ]